vaayaa Inclusive Education
Sunday, November 22, 2026Worldwide editionRSS

vaayaa News

Careers, skills and industry news from around the world

Professional · India

India's Chief Justice Calls for Regulated AI and Mandatory Legal Aid in Law Schools

At a Commonwealth legal education conference in Hyderabad, Surya Kant said AI tools should be governed by clear rules and that students must not be penalized on machine evidence alone.

By vaayaa News Desk · · 4 min read

Professional industry news

India's Chief Justice, Surya Kant, used the opening of a Commonwealth legal education conference in Hyderabad on Saturday to set out his position on artificial intelligence in law schools, calling for regulation rather than prohibition and warning that students should not be punished on the evidence of detection software alone. The two-day gathering, the first annual international conference of the Commonwealth Legal Education Association, runs on November 21 and 22 and brings together judges, vice chancellors, deans, academics and practitioners from across the Commonwealth.

The conference theme, Globalising Legal Education, focuses on how law schools should respond as AI moves into classrooms, legal research, drafting and professional practice. Organizers said the aim is to compare institutional experience across jurisdictions and identify common principles and good practices, rather than to push a single model. Hyderabad was chosen for its judicial and academic institutions and its growing technology sector.

Regulation over prohibition

The Chief Justice said an outright ban on AI tools would be neither practical nor wise, because students will enter a profession that already uses them. Generative AI can now summarize judgments, suggest arguments and produce polished answers within minutes, he noted, so the question is no longer whether students will use such tools but whether the work they submit still reflects their own reasoning. He urged institutions to set clear guidelines so that technology supports learning and research instead of replacing independent thinking.

He also questioned reliance on software that flags AI-generated text. Citing a 2023 study, he said seven widely used detectors wrongly classified more than three in five essays written by non-native English speakers as machine-generated. In a Commonwealth where many students write in English as a second or third language, he said, an honest student could be branded a cheat on the strength of a number that cannot be explained or challenged. He suggested supplementing written assessments with oral explanations, defense of legal authorities and exercises that ask students to spot errors in AI-generated answers.

The Chief Justice asked the association to take the lead in developing model guidelines on disclosing AI assistance in legal research, which law schools and journals across the Commonwealth could adapt to their own needs. He also called for common minimum standards for citing court judgments across Commonwealth countries, noting that the same decision can appear under different formats, which complicates identification and verification.

Legal aid as a graduation requirement

On access to justice, Surya Kant said legal education must reach beyond classrooms and serve people who struggle to obtain legal help. He proposed that a minimum period of legal aid work be made compulsory for every law student before graduation, with additional academic credits for those who go beyond the requirement. He also said clinical legal education, covering drafting, negotiation and real legal problems, should be an integral part of the curriculum.

Other speakers at the event took a cautious line on technology. Supreme Court judge P. S. Narasimha, the guest of honor, warned that excessive reliance on AI could weaken students' ability to reason and exercise sound judgment, and urged law schools to teach not only how to use the tools but also when to refrain. He called for human control and institutional safeguards, and for continuing education so that practicing lawyers and judges can adapt. He referred to a case in which a lawyer was barred from practice for two years after submitting a judgment that did not exist, and stressed the need to verify AI-generated material. Attorney General R. Venkataramani said legal education must respond to globalization, technology and wider social and economic change.

The debate over AI and entry-level training is also playing out in hiring. At a separate commercial litigation forum in New Delhi, Delhi High Court Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora urged law firms not to stop recruiting fresh graduates to save costs, saying the profession cannot afford to stop training its next generation. JSA managing partner Amar Gupta said the firm reserves some work entirely without AI assistance as first-level training for new associates. A survey of 146 courts and tribunals presented at that forum found that 35 percent of courts worldwide already have AI policies, and a spot poll found that 52 percent of judges want to use AI for drafting.

For students and early-career lawyers, the Hyderabad discussion signals that familiarity with AI tools is becoming part of the expected skill set, alongside the judgment to check their output. The emphasis on legal aid and clinical work also points to experience outside the classroom as a factor in how candidates are assessed. Law schools and professional bodies will be watching whether the association turns the Chief Justice's suggestions into model rules that members can adopt.

What to watch next is whether the Commonwealth Legal Education Association produces draft guidance on AI disclosure and citation standards, and whether Indian law schools move to make legal aid service a condition of graduation. Hiring patterns at large firms, and how they structure training for new associates as AI takes over routine drafting, will show how quickly the classroom debate reaches the job market. The conference closes on Sunday, with plenary sessions, thematic discussions and a senior colloquium still to come.

Written by the vaayaa News Desk, based on public reports, company statements and official data.

More Professional news

Latest from vaayaa News

Hourly Active: 40,415 Learners